Lumintop Tool, Aluminum, Copper, Brass, and Titanium Combo Review

Preface
Official Specs
Versions
Price
Short Review
Long Review
  What's Included
  Manual and Packaging
  Build Quality and Durability
  Size
  Retention
  Power
  User Interface and Operation
  Modes
  LED and beam
  Tint vs...
  Beamshots, Runtime, etc table.
  Comparisons
Conclusion
  What I like
  What I don't like
Up Next
Notes

Preface

In truth I’m probably the last flashlight person on Earth without a Lumintop Tool AAA.  But there are some variations I’ve gained interest in, and they’re also a an inexpensive way to get Nichia 219b emitters.  GearBest was kind enough to send three out for review.  After getting those three I liked them enough to purchase the Brass version for myself!

20180115-IMG_9506.jpg

This review is strictly about the AAA version of the Tool, though Lumintop has recently released an AA version.  I hope to have one of those for review soon.  (In this review I’ll refer to the Tool AAA as simply the “Tool” – I hope the schism doesn’t ruin the review, but I think the pieces fit.)

Also note that some of the photographs are from the three review items.  I did reshoot and include the brass.  But some shots are from the first photos, and don’t include the Brass.  I hope you’ll forgive that.

Here’s a link to the lights on GearBest.


Official Specs and Features

Aluminum
Titanium
Copper
Brass

Versions

Clearly there are at least 4 versions (as I am reviewing four versions here).  Massdrop also has a blue titanium version, and there are generally two emitter options, the Nichia 219b, and a Cree XP-G2.  Among the different metals and finishes, there are two switch types: a mechanical clicky, and an e-switch (both are not available in all finishes).

Price

Depending on what metal you choose, the price ranges from $10 to $40ish, with a good price for aluminum being $10, and good price for copper being $20.


Short Review

Well I liked it enough to buy my own, and it’s one of the more expensive versions.  That should qualify as a solid endorsement.

Long Review

What’s Included

  • Lumintop Tool AAA
  • Spare o-rings (2)
  • Keychain hook (depending on model)
  • Manual

20180115-IMG_9489.jpg

Package and Manual

There are two package options for the Tool.  One is a slip-fit cardboard box typical of Lumintop, and the other is a more display ready package.  This doesn’t seem to be related to the cost, metal, or switch of the light.  Some are one, some are the other.  Either is fine but the plastic case as with the Massdrop Brass and the Aluminum version is a nice bonus.

20180115-IMG_9488.jpg

The bodies that can patina, are shipped in a sealed foil pouch, so that the lights are pristine when received.  This is a nice touch.  It also meant that the Brass shipped outside it’s Massdrop-labeled case (which is fine, but I found it humorous).

20171230-IMG_9070.jpg

The manual for these lights is typical Lumintop, and fair.  The specs and features info is good, but there’s no UI description at all.

20171230-IMG_9073.jpg

Build Quality and Disassembly

I am extremely impressed with these inexpensive lights.  First off, for there to be so many versions and in so many materials, is great.  I’m a brass fan, and once I had the first three, I realized these are good lights (even at the $30 I paid from Massdrop).  In every case, the build quality is consistent and threads are smooth, and operation is flawless.

20180115-IMG_9490.jpg

20180115-IMG_9491.jpg

What held me back from ordering one of these ages ago, is that I simply did not like the shape.  I didn’t like the thin waist of the aluminum, and that turned me away from all models.  Once I have them in hand, I can say that the size and shape is just fine.

Each model has flat diamond knurling, which makes for a good grip without being overly grippy in the pocket.

All models are highly disassemblamble.  The head and tail unscrew from the center tube easily.  Inside the head and tailcap of all models, the parts are held in by threaded parts, which can just be unscrewed out of the lights.

Like-models may be Frankensteined with one exception: The titanium has a special head, and will only swap with other titanium lights.  E-tails will swap, Mechanical tails (and heads) will swap. But brass head and ti head will not.  The Titanium has a brass ring for heat dissipation from the pill.

And the Frankenstein versions don’t look half bad.

20171230-IMG_9092.jpg

One more point about build: the cell tube is reversible.  I don’t know why you’d need to do that since the clip can go on either end, but it’s still possible.  Anyway it’s nice that the light will work with the tube either direction; one less thing for a user to futz with.  The exception as usual, is the titanium, which has a male end and a female end, and is thus not reversible.

Size

The lights are around 3″ long, and very slim.  Easy to carry as a backup, and forget about.

Retention

A pocket clip is standard on all versions but the titanium.  The brass model even has a color-matching clip (though I do not think the clip is brass).  Titanium is made for a clip, but one is not included.

20180115-IMG_9493

Power

These lights are powered by a single AAA cell.  In all my testing I used an Eneloop AAA or a Ladda AAA, both NiMH cells.  There is no mention of 10440 support, and the manual states that the max driver voltage is 1.5V.  So stay away from Li-ion cells in this light.

Here’s a runtime for all 4 models that I own.  I wouldn’t read too much into the actual individual differences – the difference in relative output could be the difference in 2mm on my setup, or myriad other things.

runtime.png

Brass is surprisingly the best performer, especially compared to Titanium.  Strangely there seems to be no correlation between switch mechanism (mechanical or electronic) or special metal (brass or copper, or titanium).

One more thing about power and the e-switch lights.  These lights have a small capacitor in the tailcap, which is required for operating the e-switch.  This capacitor charges off the cell that’s placed in the light.  If your light is like mine, that capacitor might need time to charge before first use.  Usually just a few seconds, but maybe longer.  If your e-switch light doesn’t fire up right away, give that cap time to charge.

These e-switch lights also have a quiescent current of around 0.004A if I’m measuring it right (and I very well may not be).

User Interface and Operation

While these lights do have different switches, the operation is largely the same.  Tools with the rubber boot have reverse mechanical clickies. Tools without the rubber boot have metal e-switches.  The UI is also very simple.  Click for on, click for off.  Clicking on quickly enough, will advance the modes.  All but Brass go HML, while brass goes LMH.  E-switch variants must be clicked off and on to advance modes, but the mechanical may be half pressed to advance.

The mechanical clickies are extremely clicky.  I mean they click with extreme prejudice.  The e-switches are much quieter, but flat across the top and can be less easy to find.  They’re also metal switches, whereas the mechanical have big rubber boots with lots of grip.

20180115-IMG_9506.jpg

There really seems to be no hidden modes on these lights.  Just three modes, no strobe, no turbo, etc.  I quite like it.

Modes

Mode Mode Claimed Output (lm) Claimed Runtime Mode Measured Lux
High 80 30m 1712
Mid 18 4h 518
Low 3 36h 54

LED and Beam

All of my Tools have Nichia 219b emitters.  There’s also available a Cree XP-G2 version, which I recommend avoiding unless you hate life.  And color. And accurate color representation and awesome tint.  If you already have a Tool XP-G2 we can still be friends, though.

20180115-IMG_9496.jpg

The beam profile is mostly spot with some spill, and glorious 219b tint.

Tint vs BLF-348

20180118-IMG_9654.jpg

Tool at left in the above photo.  The tint is really fairly consistent across these four lights, so take this as a representative sample.  Also the tint across 219b’s isn’t entirely consistent, so the difference in these tints won’t correlate strictly speaking to what you receive no matter which you purchase.

I’m dissatisfied that the Tool doesn’t match the BLF-348, which has my favorite tint, really.  Also 219b.

Beamshots, Runtime, and Lux Measurements

Lumintop Tool Lumintop Tool Titanium Lumintop Tool Copper Lumintop Tool Brass
Emitter Nichia 219b
Cell AAA
Glamour Shots Beamshots [0.3″, f/8, ISO 100, 5000k]
LVP? Warning
Claimed Lumens (lm) na 0.0004 na 0.0004
Lux (Measured) 80 lux @ 66 m 80 lux @ 64 m 80 lux @ 62 m 80 lux @ 51 m
Candela (Calculated) in cd 2.4 2.5 2.5 2.7
Throw (Calculated) (m) 378.9 403.2 395 369
Throw (Claimed) (m) 38.9 40.16 39.74799175 38.42088495

 

Random Comparisons and Competitive Options….

There are some great competitors for this light.  One I have experience with is the Eagtac D25AAA, also available with a Nichia emitter.  I absolutely loved this little light, except it’s a twisty, and has too-easily-accessed strobe modes. And it’s been available for cheap ($10), too!  No special metals, though, and that’s something I love about the Tool.

Conclusion

What I like

  • Size
  • Special metal availability
  • Simple UI
  • No excess of modes
  • Different switch types
  • Available in Nichia
  • Low cost

What I don’t like

  • I wish for better tint from the Nichia – like my BLF-348
  • UI lottery.  Some are LMH, some are HML.

Up Next

Next week I plan to finish a Thrunite and a Nitecore, and possibly a light by Acebeam.  Not sure what else is on the agenda!

Notes

  • This light was provided by GearBest (and I liked those three so much I bought the brass version!) for review. I was not paid to write this review.
  • This content originally appeared at zeroair.wordpress.com.  Please visit there for the best experience!
  • Whether or not I have a coupon for this light, I do have a bunch of coupons!!  Have a look at my spreadsheet for those coupons.  Note I’ve upgraded that sheet so that now, you may subscribe and get notifications when the sheet is edited!!
Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Lumintop Tool, Aluminum, Copper, Brass, and Titanium Combo Review

Add yours

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Create a website or blog at WordPress.com

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: